top of page

Hi here below you can see my portfolio of work for module 5153MAPA Media Law In Action.

​

My 900 word count is made up through two seperate reports, one being from Coventry Magistrates court and one being from Coventry Crown Court.

Court report 1:Ronnie Bird, harassment and stalking. 

Word count: 441

 

Coventry man escapes restraining order 

 

A local Coventry man has avoided charges today (Thursday 10th October)  Ronnie Bird has been accused of harassment and stalking by his ex-partner of which he sent a myriad of emotional, long-winded emails to despite being no longer together. A restraining order against Ronnie was denied in Coventry Magistrates Court this afternoon after the Jury heard statements from both Ronnie himself and his ex-partner. 

 

These accusations span between August and November of 2023 in which Ronnie repeatedly contacted the woman even after her expressing multiple times that she no longer wanted to hear from him after his relentless contact was causing her ‘considerable distress’ as heard by the prosecution. 

 

In December of 2022 Ronnie had sent an email indicating he was aware of the relationship being over however, the email went on to express his love for her even asking her to meet him at the local pub. This contact was pushed and continued by Ronnie even continuing into August of 2023 in which the woman had replied with ‘no, I want nothing more to do with you’. The same day this message was sent (23rd August), Ronnie went on to send another email later that evening. 

 

A few days later, 30th August, Ronnie was still relentlessly contacting her even going as far to address her as ‘Babe’ and asking to visit her home address. The prosecution made a point that her replies to him were sent out of fear that if she did not respond, he would come to her house. 

 

Another one of these letters sent on the 14th November 2023 was four pages long, regardless of it being imperative the woman wanted no more contact with Mr Bird. 

 

The prosecution questioned Ronnie intensely in court asking him ‘how many times does she have to tell you no for you to listen?’ in which Ronnie shook his head in dismissal, claiming he was unbeknown to how unwelcome his contact was, the prosecution even asking him ‘did you give it any thought?’.

 

Ronnie even went as far to appear on the same flight as the woman who was on her way to visit family in Spain despite the two of them no longer being romantically involved. The last point of contact was after Mr Bird had been arrested, he sent a letter from prison stating he ‘had found God’ and was seeking forgiveness. 

 

Despite all this evidence against Ronnie, the defence ruled that he was ‘unaware’ of the severity of his actions as he would ‘normally rekindle a romance a few months after’. They also ruled that he showed ‘no threats of violence’ and therefore had not contributed to any kind of harassment.

Crown court report: Child one

Word count: 349

 

Parents accused of causing the death of their 3 year old child 

 

The parents of a three-year-old boy, whose body was found buried in the garden of their home in Birmingham appeared in Coventry crown court today, Thursday 24th October. 

 

Dr Sally Andrews, a forensic odontologist took the stand in front of the jury to relay dental evidence she had collected. Tai – zamarai aged 42, and Naiyahmi Yasharahyalah, 43 have been accused of allowing or causing the death of their young child named Abiyah. 

Abiyah’s remains were discovered to be severely malnourished and the prosecution states that both parents 'prioritised cultural beliefs and practises over their child's welfare with disastrous consequences'. Dr Sally Andrews described the dental records found as ‘abnormal’ and ‘very poor’. This included extensive decay and the bones being visually ‘porotic in appearance’. As a result of these findings, it was concluded that Abiyah had inadequate amounts of calcium required for development and as a result suffered extreme dental problems. 

One of the problems shared in court consisted of clear evidence of infection and/or abscesses. This was discovered by the lack of ‘bony support’ around his teeth and as a result it was concluded that Abiyah likely suffered extreme discomfort and pain. Dr Sally Andres also stated that if Abiyah had survived, his dental condition would be extremely difficult to rescue, Dr Andrews even described his dental condition to be one of the worst cases she had seen in her career. 

 

Further bone disease was found in Abiyahs jaw which also indicates the general lack on structural integrity, Dr Andrews went on to further describe Abiyahs enamel as ‘strikingly thin, thinner than an eggshell’ denoting an obvious lack of dental hygiene during his life.  Many factors came into this including a lack of vitamin D and calcium, without these essential substances it’s easy for teeth to fall into a state of decay.

Dr Andrews also addressed the court explaining that this situation was progressively worsening during Abiyahs life, his dental development at birth was pronounced as ‘normal’ leading the prosecution to believe that his parents played a damaging role when it came to his death. The trial continues. 

Reflective essay: 

Word count: 628

 

Studying this module was extremely interesting, learning about the different laws in place and being able to apply this knowledge in my own reports was an overall huge learning experience. 

 

As journalists we are all given a responsibility to report fairly, and to ensure that news is reported with ‘due accuracy and presented with due impartiality’[1] this is imperative to follow as it ensures information is not manipulated or warped by bias or any other factor. This is also protected by IPSO (Independent Press Standards Organisation) an independent regulator of the UK news and digital print industry. [2] IPSO’s editors code of practice is quoted as ‘the framework used to uphold the highest professional standards’ [3]. When completing my court reports, applying this code was essential, more specifically following Clause One: Accuracy. It states that ‘The press must take care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorted information or images, including headlines not supported by the text’[4]. Clause One was extremely important to follow when writing my own court report as I had to rely on my own notes and facts that I had gathered. This was however helped by IPSO’s public information on court reporting which states journalists are allowed to ‘go to court and report anything which is said or given as evidence in court’ [5] this was applied to my own assignment as I was able to name those involved and share evidence heard without having to stray including naming Ronnie Bird and quoting the evidence giving in his hearing. This ultimately helped me build cohesive, detailed court reports which represent accuracy and follow IPSO’s regulations.

 

During this module we went on multiple trips to both courts and witnessed a range of trials in front of a jury. The Crown court deals with the most serious crimes whilst the Magistrates court delas with over 90% of cases including sexual assault, burglaries and dangerous driving[6] these hearings are formally known as summary proceedings. When criminals are arrested for Indictable offences, it firstly goes to the magistrate’s court before being immediately transferred to the Crown court for a trial[7] . My own experience saw three very different cases ranging from a harassment and stalking case to a child neglect case. 

 

Ethical issues that I faced when completing this assignment consisted of the ability to name the child in the Crown Court case, whilst being able to name the child t was still important it this followed IPSO’s Editors Code of Practice as Clause 9 states ‘particular regard should be paid to the potentially vulnerable position of children under the age of 18 who witness, or are victims of, crime.’[8] This directly applied to my assignment as the Crown Court case dealt with extremely sensitive, saddening details about the remains of a three year old child being discovered at a house in Birmingham. Although the child’s name was publicly shared extreme care was taken when reporting on the hearing despite the graphic details.

 

Overall throughout this module I have gained more legal knowledge when it comes to reporting, this will benefit me as a future journalist as I now have more confidence and industry experience. 

 

 

 

[1] The Ofcom Broadcasting Code (with the Cross-promotion Code and the On Demand Programme Service Rules). (2020, December 31). www.ofcom.org.uk. https://www.ofcom.org.uk/tv-radio-and-on-demand/broadcast-standards/broadcast-code

 

[2] Home - IPSO. (2024, July 23). IPSO. https://www.ipso.co.uk/

 

[3] The Editors’ Code of Practice - IPSO. (2024, July 11). IPSO. https://www.ipso.co.uk/editors-code-of-practice/

 

[4] The Editors’ Code of Practice - IPSO. (2024b, July 11). IPSO. https://www.ipso.co.uk/editors-code-of-practice/

 

[5] Court Reporting:
What to expect - IPSO. (2024b, August 23). IPSO. https://www.ipso.co.uk/resources-guidance/advice-and-information-for-the-public/court-reporting-what-to-expect/

 

[6] Dodd, M., & Hanna, M. (2018). McNae's essential law for journalists. Oxford University Press.

[7] Crook, T. (n.d.). The BJTC Media Law, Regulation & Ethics Handbook 2021. https://bjtc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/BJTCMediaLawRegulationEthicsHandbook2021-1.pdf

‌

 

[8] The Editors’ Code of Practice - IPSO. (2024c, July 11). IPSO. https://www.ipso.co.uk/editors-code-of-practice/

© 2035 by Artist Corner. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page